Power Without Glory is one of the most controversial and politically explosive novels in Australian literary history. First published in April 1950, the novel traces the rise of fictional Melbourne powerbroker John West, a working-class Irish Catholic who ascends from poverty to immense wealth and political influence through gambling syndicates, backroom deals, corruption, intimidation, and manipulation.
Set primarily between the 1890s and mid-20th century Melbourne, the novel explores:
The machinery of political patronage
The intertwining of gambling, unions, church and government
Class loyalty versus ambition
The moral cost of power
Media influence and public manipulation
West constructs a vast network of influence spanning:
Victorian Labor politics
Municipal councils
Police and criminal elements
Catholic Church leadership
Trade unions
The novel portrays how political and financial empires are built not by ideals but through calculated power plays. Hardy’s tone is investigative, detailed, and overtly ideological — reflecting his membership of the Communist Party of Australia at the time.
The Real-Life Controversy
Although presented as fiction, the central character John West was widely understood to be based on Melbourne businessman and Labor figure John Wren.
Other thinly veiled real-life parallels included:
Archbishop Daniel Malone (based on Archbishop Daniel Mannix)
Kenneth Murkett (based on Keith Murdoch)
Lou Darby (based on boxer Les Darcy)
Shortly after publication, Hardy was arrested and charged with criminal libel over allegations that the novel implied an extramarital affair involving Ellen Wren (wife of John Wren). The case became a cause célèbre in Cold War Australia.
Hardy was acquitted in December 1950.
The prosecution — widely viewed by some as politically motivated — only increased the book’s notoriety and sales.
Historical Context
The novel was published during a period of intense political anxiety:
Post-World War II tensions
Early Cold War paranoia
Establishment of ASIO in 1949
Prime Minister Robert Menzies’ anti-communist campaign
Commercial publishers refused to handle the manuscript. As a result, Hardy helped establish the Realist Printing & Publishing Company to produce the first edition.
The first edition was effectively self-published under semi-clandestine conditions, with printing, storage, collation and binding dispersed across sympathetic union and party networks.
Estimates suggest 5,000–10,000 copies were produced.
First Edition Significance (April 1950)
The April 1950 first edition is the most collectible issue because:
It was the edition involved in the criminal libel prosecution
It contains known printing irregularities
It predates the October 1950 second edition
It represents one of Australia’s most notorious banned novels
Notable printing anomaly:
The chapter heading “Decline of Power” appears prematurely in page headers (pp. 533, 537, 541, 545, 547, 549), although the chapter formally begins at page 551.
Fourteen illustrated chapter initials were contributed by Ambrose Dyson.
The April 1950 first edition is collectible and increasingly sought after.
Power Without Glory | Frank J Hardy (April 1950 First Edition) | Banned Book
Title: Power Without Glory | A Novel in Three Parts
Author: Frank J Hardy
Edition: First Edition
Publication Date: April 1950
Publisher: Realist Printing & Publishing Co, Melbourne
Binding: Hardcover
Pages: 669 pages
Condition: Red cloth boards. Some shelf wear and rubbing to boards. Age toning to pages. No dust jacket (as issued, many first editions were sold without formal jackets). Structurally sound. Overall: Very Good
ISBN: N/A
































